Religion

The Evolution of Hobby Lobby: The Arguments that Matter and How They Were Developed

By: Micah J. Schwartzman, Richard C. Schragger, and Nelson Tebbe

How will the Supreme Court decide the question of religious exemptions in Hobby Lobby? We are not in the prediction business, and although we would like to think we have some sense of how the justices reason about these issues, there is no need to guess at the outcomes. We will all know soon enough. But in anticipating the Court’s decision, it is worth noting how fast this litigation has proceeded—from the trial court to the Supreme Court in 15 months—and how rapidly the legal arguments on both sides evolved during that very short time period. Whatever the Court decides, we are fairly confident that it will address issues that were not squarely presented in the lower courts. 

Permanent Link: https://www.religiousfreedominstitute.org/cornerstone/2016/6/16/the-evolution-of-hobby-lobby-the-arguments-that-matter-and-how-they-were-developed